Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Daring Bakers - December 2011: Sourdough Bread

Courtesy of King Arthur Flour
Our Daring Bakers Host for December 2011 was Jessica of My Recipe Project and she showed us how fun it is to create Sour Dough bread in our own kitchens! She provided us with Sour Dough recipes from Bread Matters by AndrewWhitley as well as delicious recipes to use our Sour Dough bread in from Tonia George’s Things on Toast and Canteen’s Great British Food!

Let me first say that I love sourdough bread.  Anytime I see a grilled toasty sandwich on sourdough, I'll take it!  As for the sourdough making process, I can't say it was an enjoyable process.  Even the science nerd in me was kind of grossed out.

unlike regular bread, sourdough bread is made from a starter, and has no yeast.  No yeast?  Well, you ask, how does it rise?  The starter is a mass of fermented water and flour.  The recipe Jessica provided consisted of flour and water left to ferment in a covered container for several days.  Periodically, you feed the starter with more flour and water. 

All starter well in the beginning, I could see it starting to bubble away on the counter, and I dutifully fed it each day.  However, by day 4, it had stopped bubbling, and a layer of greyish liquid had formed on top.  Not sure what to do, I proceeded with the recipe, hoping it would still do something.  After the final feeding/refreshing, I was ready to bake.  It looked like the thing that ate Manhattan, and stank to high heaven!  But, reading other DBers' posting who said that it would be an extremely wet and loose dough, I kept going.  I don't have any pictures of the blob because it would have dripped off the counter onto the flour if I'd tried to take pictures.

I waited for it to proof and rise.  And waited...and waited... and waited.  Nothing.  I hoped it would have some oven spring.  Nope.  My final project was flat, dense, greyish in color, and not at all edible.


  1. Well dang! It looks good! I think December was a bad month to do sourdough, its just too cold in everyone's house!! Try again, and next time nestle that baby up warm and toasty! I usually put mine in the oven with the light on or on top of the dryer, with it running.

  2. I am sorry that your starter didn't start well for you... I hope that you don't lose too much hope, and that you find a way to make your own sourdough soon!

  3. I'm so interested in the Amish Bread Starter you mentioned on the forum--I was hoping you had a post about it here.

    Very sorry about the disappointing time you had with this challenge. I'm sure it was the cold of winter that had a bad impact on the rise-ability of our breads.

    Happy New Year, and here's to many Happy Challenges! :)

  4. Too bad it didn't turn out for you :( I'm also interested to hear more about the Amish Friendship Bread!

  5. My sourdough wasn't really edible either. It posed for a picture before being tossed in the garbage. Better luck next time!

  6. Thanks all for stopping by! I will be posting about the Amish Friendship bread in the next day or two. Here's a link to the starter recipe and a wide variety of things to make with the starter.


Search This Blog